NW Reviews: She & Him – Volume Two
I’ve been hyped off of the idea that this indie-surf-pop thing is going to take off this year. Promising first track, She & Him gets my hopes up. The scenester super combo of Zooey Deschanel and M. Ward can safely produce mediocre music together and sell more songs than Zooey did for “The Fabric of Our Lives”.
Aside from partial commercial successes, how is Volume Two? And does is topic the mostly “meh” efforts of Volume One?
The first few songs do strike decent, however nothing special. Oh yeah, after the first track, “Thieves”, the surf vibe leaves and comes back in with what M. Ward would probably make up on his indie-pop spare time. I prefer Zooey and M. Ward’s combo over just M. Ward on his own mainly because Zooey can sing. M. Ward has some abilities himself, but I feel that if you haven’t been shot with the M. Ward arrow, it’s hard to just pick up a recent album and get into it (especially with that awkward voice of his). Zooey lightens this music a lot.
In fact, this album reminds me much of one of my more favorite albums by Saturday Looks Good to Me, Every Night. Zooey definitely bests out the pretty Betty Marie Barnes, but in the same vain I believe M. Ward and Fred Thomas from SLGtM share a similar taste in this indie-pop dig. With that, did Zooey and M. Ward best the efforts of SLGtM? I would say so. But that isn’t saying that much is it? How did it fair compared to some of the better albums of this year?
It’s hard not to start picking up the lyrics for this album and start belting. It’s so catchy! What the heck?! It also makes me want to buy a leather jacket and a Chevy Bel-Air and say yes to the first poodle-skirted girl who asks me to the Sadie Hawkins dance. I imagine I’d be listening to this on a jukebox that has Volume Two on vinyl. Maybe Potsy, Ralph, and Richie Cunningham will meet me at Arthur’s and I can be the new Fonz. You can’t replace the Fonz, but at least She & Him can replace high school dance music from the 60s. Is that really a pro?
Somewhere between the lines of catchy music and infectious lyrics is something a little more plain. The song writing itself seems lacking. Sure, your head is bobbing and you want to slow dance with your best friend to this, but KC and JoJo made you want to do that too. You don’t want me to compare Zooey and M. Ward to KC and JoJo do you? No, you don’t. Another con to this album is maybe the freshness versus the inventiveness. Freshness value: not so high. We have this music in tons of different forms. I mentioned SLGtM already. Best Coast and Real Estate touch on bases that She & Him touch on as well. So, with low freshness, you want a much higher inventiveness. Unfortunately, there isn’t much there as far as pushing themselves to a brink. I find myself liking the songs but not loving the songs. I’m not blown away by inventiveness. It’s not like a Owen Pallett Heartland or a self-titled album from Fang Island. It’s more like what American Dollar Atlas brought to post-rock this year. It tastes new but isn’t impressing an image on my mind as much as I want it to.
–
People who would like this: people who like indie-pop. It’s hard to go wrong with this album as far as indie-pop is concerned. It’s maybe closer to the prototypical indie-pop sound than I want to believe. Others who would like this: people who like Happy Days.
I don’t see this album chiming in against any other bands at the midseason in June. This means that I’m not going to see this album competing for an album of the year position. Maybe a little more magic and less magic tricks next time, scene-team? Mediocre isn’t great, but it isn’t bad. So I guess…
p.s. Here’s a bonus video of my favorite She & Him song from this album. Enjoy!












