NW Reviews: Midterm Reports
Many readers (that’s an embellished statement) have commented about the rating system I have, specifically about the “Album of the Year” rating. For the record, I’ve reviewed 38 albums this year, 8 of which have been “bad” reviews. Out of the other 30 albums I have reviewed, 7 have been graced with the “album of the year” nomination tag. Now that it is midterms, which is half way between the final verdict of albums of the year, I would like to go back and reconsider some albums that did not receive a nomination and those that did. These aren’t set in stone, but as far as up and coming new music is concerned… this is my personal pick of the litter.
To restate what the rating system is all about: the rating system works very black-and-white. Although there is no complete and streamlined way to get the “Album of the Year” nomination, much of the review boils down to whether or not you pass the “good” or “bad” rating system. All “bad” albums will never see the light of any nomination from this site. What makes up a bad album? Here’s the breakdown:
-Music quality — How good is your music on a surface level? What makes you one of the best artists/bands in your genre?
-New music ability — What makes this album “current”? What makes this album the pioneer for more albums of this type of genre or style? How many other artists/bands are playing this type of genre/style?
-Recording/Production value — Where did you record this? Pro studio? Laundry room? Who did you record it with? Did they adjust live song demo flaws with studio adjustments? Did they conjure a new sound out of an artist that seems signature to the producer? Is there over-production or under-production? Does the editing and mastering sound balanced? What is being portrayed as the lead instruments? What needs to be turned up? What is lacking in performance or volume or etc?
Those are the three areas I look for. They are rated in that priority listing you see above. Music quality is given the most regard, followed by new music ability and then production value. For a nomination in my “Album of the Year” category an album must AT LEAST meet these three areas. The hardest to envision is the new music ability portion of my rating system. Within a year, many tastes in the indie scene vary. For a while throughout my high school, hardcore punk and “screamo” type indie bands existed heavily. Within months, the taste changed to this indie-folk and math-rock/indie-pop phase. Months exist within a year. If I am to evaluate what is fresh and current and new in the scene, I need more than just a few hours with one album. Context is definitely needed. With that said, let’s view the most updated list of albums nominated:
–
(click an album to read my full article!)
From the outset, I pegged Mr. Pallett to be one of the star candidates in the race for that ever-evolving “singer/songwriter” title. This album shows versatility in that saturated “s/sw” world, incorporating the violin, an instrument harder to master than just an acoustic guitar and paired with effects and loop pedals made for the guitar. The product is some very interesting music from a very interesting man.
Joanna Newsom – Have One On Me
The highly-anticipated release from Joanna Newsom did not disappoint. After four years of waiting, Newsom comes back with a more mature and artistic approach to her music and songwriting. A three-disc album, the ambitious Newsom impressed with her quirky vocals and masterful playing of multiple instruments to keep all the boys drooling for more. Although trying to shoot the moon, Ms. Newsom will find tough competition as her album fades further back in the minds of the indie world.
Take every possibly-pop sounding Sigur Ros song out there, flip the switch from complex orchestra to bedroom band oriented, and throw in lyrics that kind of make sense. You’ve got yourself a concoction close to Jonsi’s (of Sigur Ros) newest album. A very far cry from “of the norm” s/sw albums, Jonsi brings his unique vocals and strong songwriting capabilities to the indie-pop world. Interesting and very fun.
Never heard of them? Nor had we until we got this album from the fine folks at Sargent House. Somewhere between sprinting and cartwheeling is where you can find most of these songs. Fun, energetic, and all about the stage diving, Fang Island does not skimp on the rocker jams. In a world of much seriousness and dark malady, Fang Island is a care-free ray of hope for the dance pit and stage diving world.
Fan of Highly Refined Pirates and Menos el Oso? So am I. Which is why Omni is totally a puzzle piece to the Minus the Bear legacy. The introduction of all the new elements on this album give way to all the things that used to make Minus the Bear the uncontested party band and party music of my early college years. Now, nearing the end of my educational career, Minus the Bear revitalizes themselves with this album. Cheap lyrics? Fine. But just listen to how Dave Knudson (guitar) doesn’t play guitar at all! Rather, the omnichord synthesizer. Can you say “new trendy instrument”? I’ll see you in 2011, omnichord.
Pretentious? Possibly. Arrogant? Who knows. Amazing? Possibly one of the best albums of this year. The against-the-grain style of blues, folk, and rock met with the blessings of such artists like Led Zeppelin can only equate to something amazing. Maybe the most classiest and tasteful mixes of instrumentation and vocals this year.
–
Here are a few extra candidates, now having time to look back on the past six months:
Although I’ve only been on the fence about nominating this album for a few days… comparing it to other releases this year, this album is very full. I think that is the most appropriate way to describe it. Full. From start to end, it’s very easy to say this album will be getting a lot of street cred from many scenes around town.
Believe me, the bandwagon is filling up. I’m glad I got on it somewhere between “halfway full” and “fire hazard imminent”. The hype for Local Natives lately is well deserved, however. Coming off a very good year in the US, their album (which originally released in the UK last year) has been gathering critical US acclaim. Now on their way to a Summer of international touring and festival shows, Local Natives’ Gorilla Manor seems to be the start of something very good.
This year has been a very heavy year for post-rock bands across the board. For a few weeks out of the past six months, I actually thought this blog turned into a post-rock blog at times. The first post-rock album of this year that I reviewed still seems to be the album to beat. The American Dollar is something along the lines of catchy, which is practically impossible for most post-rock songs. The American Dollar is also along the lines of classic, which usually you only hold the “classic” title in the post-rock realm to Godspeed You! Black Emperor. Something in the way this band sounds like a few guys jamming in a garage crossed with very sleek electronics and song structures make these guys a very heavy contender for not only post-rock album but instrumental album of the year.
–
The only album that was a past nominee and is now an album I wouldn’t consider is this:
The Magic Theatre – London Town
Putting this album up against any of the other aforementioned albums is like putting Justin Bieber into a MMA fight. The quirkiness, the catchiness, the charm and Liverpool swagger The Magic Theatre brings to the table all adds up to one missing piece: more originality. Although I might be stepping on some toes above, The Magic Theatre’s claim to the list was that The Magic Theatre’s genre would be the next “it” genre. We’ve heard of fun., Forgive Durden, and Say Anything(‘s latest album), but since then not many bands (new or past) have stepped up the pseudo-showtunes genre. As such, this new music will be favored by some, but not revered by many.
–
With that, six of the previous seven albums are still in the fight and three new additions have made it. I’m only one person, and although I’m not pumping out quantities of reviews and other things like my friend at TheAlbumProject, I’m trying to censor a good amount of… well… mediocrity and bad albums. So, although I’ve only reviewed 38 albums that were published on this site, here are some other stats some people into the “behind the scenes” stuff might be into:
-This year, I’ve received 82 albums (in counting) from labels, management, and indie artists
-I’ve listened to every single album once.
-On average, that’s about 40ish hours of music listened to once.
-About half of these albums are either non-indie albums that I won’t review, albums from last year I won’t review, or very very bad.
-A small percentage of albums are decent but unimpressive and/or new music. 80s metal bands still? Seriously? I won’t review that.
-The other half see the light of a review. Each album I listen to at least three times. Once for initial take-in. A second time for analysis. And a third while I’m writing the review. Most albums get more than that, as I usually just walk around with a full iPod most of the day.
-In time, this averages to at least 57 hours of reviewed music listened to. Add that to the unreviewed albums and you get a total of at least 61 hours of music listened to this year.
–
To conclude, if you want to help write (teeheehee…) just email me. nick at 402 productions dot com. Let me know what you want to write about and if you have some samples (very recommended). You don’t have to put in five days of straight up listening and reviewing new music, but it’d definitely help me out.
–
Six months and a few days from now, a new album will be crowned album of the year. Hope you stick around!






















