Album Reviews: Anna Vogelzang – Canary In A Coal Mine
Recently, Nick Wan wrote an interesting piece centering on the concept of selling out, and how no matter how much corporate sponsorship or how many Youtube hits a band gets, the absolute best approach to building a fan base is a holistic one: practice your ass off, play a million shows, talk to people, and be around for longer than a week before you try to say you’ve made it.
Anna Vogelzang has been around longer than a week; more like a decade at this point. She’s a mainstay of the Midwest DIY folk scene. She writes, records, promotes, performs, and even teaches at a girl’s rock camp. She’s done this without the backing of a label, funding her newest full-length, Canary In A Coal Mine, via Kickstarter. Anna has built not only a moderate following (a random dude in a bowling alley in Seattle told me last month that he has seen Vogelzang live twice) but some critical acclaim as well for her voice and songwriting, both of which are at their finest on Canary In A Coal Mine.
Listen to “Volcanoes” While You Read
The Pros
Everything about this album shines, but for me the biggest gold nugget is the lyricism. I often play a game when I listen to an album for the first time: I pick random lines and try to guess the coming rhyme, if not the next line in its entirety. You can play this game with almost any genre (you win again, classical music!) and I personally believe that you can tell a lot about how good a writer is by trying to predict their writing. I am about as far from a good songwriter as a Bengal tiger is from a stapler– I’m just a dude who listens to a LOT of music– so if I can predict half of your lines, you may not be trying very hard.
There’s no issue with that on Canary In A Coal Mine. Vogelzang’s lyrics are crisp, fresh, and constantly engaging. There’s hope, despair, humor, rage, heartbreak, and silliness in these songs, the wordplay and imagery slip-sliding in such a way that it’s nearly impossible to predict. Here is one example, chosen not because it’s the best example, but because it is literally playing as I type:
“My fuse is itching to run out
Is there machinery you could bring?
See, I was born into this broken mess
not even miles seem to fix.
With every day, a little death
and I hope that trip is beautiful
but maybe the gears that grind against your wheels
could spark a kickstart to my chest.”
–from “Heart Beat Faster”
The Cons
Almost none, honestly. Folk may not be your thing, and that’s cool, but in terms of songwriting, arranging, vocal performance, and overall construction– production, pacing, etc.– Canary in a Coal Mine is almost flawless.
The Verdict
Lately I’ve been listening to a lot of solo female folk: Emily Hurd, Fay Wolf, and Gillian Welch off the top of my head, but Canary in a Coal Mine is the best new folk album I’ve heard in a really long time. It’s the best example I currently have for how bright the future of music can be: give an artist with a unique vision a few dollars and creative control then step back and wait for the magic to happen.
















