Album Reviews: The Mountain Goats – All Eternals Deck

When you put on a Bob Dylan record, whether it’s Blood On The Tracks or Under The Red Sky, you know it’s a Dylan record though the two albums have little in sonic relation. It’s rare to find an artist with such a strongly developed core sound that isn’t afraid to switch the formula up on a regular basis. The transition for John Darnielle has been a slow one– for a decade and a half he essentially was The Mountain Goats, only making the unit an official trio in 2008, but since 2005′s The Sunset Tree every Mountain Goats release has broken new ground in terms of subject, sound, and atmosphere. And from the opening plunking guitar, meandering piano chords, and calls to the “brave young cowboys of the near north side”, All Eternals Deck feels like a Mountain Goats record. And a bit more as well.
Watch “Birth Of Serpents” Live On Letterman
The Pros
All Eternals Deck has everything you would expect from a Darnielle release: simple (though not simplistic) arrangements and image-laden lyrics sung with great conviction. But he steps his game up a notch: “Estate Sale Sign” is perhaps the single most aggressive track in the entire Mountain Goats catalog, like “Dilaudid” if you replaced the cello with snake venom. On “High Hawk Season” we have a near-full barbershop quartet. And on “Outer Scorpion Squadron” and the excellent “Never Quite Free” Darnielle actually sings.
Listen To “Estate Sale Sign”
The Cons
Everyone knows that Darnielle’s lyrics can occasionally cross a line into the land of trying-so-hard-to-be-deep-its-shallow– at this point that’s like complaining about the quaver in Conor Oberst’s voice on any Bright Eyes album. Much like that quaver’s slow retreat from recent Oberst recordings, Darnielle’s lyrics have become more focused and precise. Almost (gulp!) understated. Some of the most effective lines on All Eternals Deck don’t immediately jump out at you– they settle in devastatingly slow.
A more pressing complaint is that the album starts like many other Mountain Goats albums, and there is a real danger that those ambivalent towards previous Mountain Goats releases will quit before things get really interesting. If you previewed this on Amazon or itunes but was turned away after “Damn These Vampires” and “Birth of Serpents”, give it another shot– this time starting from somewhere in the middle.
The Verdict
The world of music criticism is famously fickle, especially in an age where the combination of two or three web sites can cause a tsunami of hype from which no band could escape. But John Darnielle has maintained a longevity as a critical (bordering on commercial) darling basically ever since he picked up a guitar and began recording songs about Quetzalcoatl on a shitty boombox. Since those days each new project has felt similar yet tangibly different. It’s a testament to Darnielle’s talent and, like Dylan’s ability to be any one else in music and Dylan at the same time, it’s really special. I’m not willing to nominate this for album of the year just yet, but it was a slow first quarter so when we do our mid-year round-up, don’t be surprised if this is listed.







